| Joey T | Matt J | Dan S | Gy M | Jr | Al J | Gavin W | Mukul J | Sibany | Melissa P | Tim L |
| Rd. 1 | Henrik Sedin (5) | Sidney Crosby (8) | Evgeni Malkin (8) | Marian Gaborik (12) | Daniel Sedin (2) | James Neal (6) | Tyler Seguin (4) | Ilya Kovalchuk (20) | Roberto Luongo (0) | Brad Richards (15) | Henrik Lundqvist (21) |
| Rd. 2 | Tim Thomas (6.5) | Marian Hossa (0) | Ryan Kesler (3) | Kris Letang (6) | Patrice Bergeron (2) | Pavel Datsyuk (3) | Pekka Rinne (9.5) | Marc-Andre Fleury (3) | Alexandre Burrows (1) | David Backes (4) | Jordan Staal (12) |
| Rd. 3 | David Krejci (3) | Patrick Kane (4) | Andy McDonald (11) | Alexander Edler (2.5) | Milan Lucic (3) | Henrik Zetterberg (3) | Patrick Sharp (1) | Chris Kunitz (6) | Kevin Bieksa (2) | Chris Higgins (0) | Alex Ovechkin (10) |
| Rd. 4 | Martin Brodeur (24) | Duncan Keith (1) | Steve Sullivan (6) | Martin Erat (4) | Alexander Radulov (6) | Jimmy Howard (1.5) | Scott Hartnell (9) | Pascal Dupuis (6) | Claude Giroux (21) | Alex Pietrangelo (5.5) | Ryan Callahan (10) |
| Rd. 5 | Zach Parise (17) | Jonathan Toews (5) | Jaroslav Halak (3.5) | Shea Weber (4) | Patrik Elias (9) | Zdeno Chara (4) | Anze Kopitar (25) | Johan Franzen (2) | David Booth (1) | Derek Stepan (9) | Mike Fisher (4) |
| Rd. 6 | Joe Thornton (5) | Viktor Stalberg (2) | David Perron (6) | David Legwand (8) | Michael DelZotto (13) | Rich Peverley (5) | Brad Marchand (2) | Mike Smith (19.5) | Dan Hamhuis (4.5) | Matt Cooke (4) | Ryan Suter (5.5) |
| Rd. 7 | Logan Couture (4) | Corey Crawford (3) | Valtteri Filppula (2) | Brian Campbell (8) | Patric Hornqvist (4) | Niklas Kronwall (3) | Jonathan Quick (32) | Ray Whitney (8) | Jaromir Jagr (9) | Carl Hagelin (3) | Radim Vrbata (5) |
| Rd. 8 | Keith Yandle (10.5) | Dave Bolland (3) | Tyler Kennedy (7) | Brandon Dubinsky (2) | Danny Briere (14) | Erik Karlsson (1.5) | Drew Doughty (21) | Patrick Marleau (0) | Nicklas Backstrom (9) | Maxim Lapierre (1) | Martin Havlat (4) |
| Rd. 9 | Shane Doan (11) | Brent Seabrook (3) | T.J. Oshie (3) | Joe Pavelski (0) | Adam Henrique (17) | Jason Spezza (6) | Stephen Weiss (5) | Martin Hanzal (8) | Ilya Bryzgalov (7.5) | Kevin Shattenkirk (2) | Antti Niemi (1.5) |
| Rd. 10 | Brian Elliott (6.5) | Andrew Shaw (0) | Mason Raymond (1) | Brian Rolston (3) | Brent Burns (2.5) | Dustin Brown (27) | Kris Versteeg (6) | Dan Boyle (2.5) | Alexander Semin (5) | Paul Martin (1) | Cory Schneider (1.5) |
| TOTAL | 92.5 | 29 | 50.5 | 49.5 | 72.5 | 60 | 114.5 | 75 | 60 | 44.5 | 74.5 |