| Joey T | Dan S | Tim L | Gy M | Ryan F | Mike S | Gavin W | Melissa P | Mukul J | Mike G | |
| Round 1 |  MacKinnon (19) |  McDavid (4) |  Matthews (6) |  Rantanen (15) |  Kucherov (33) |  Makar (13) |  Stone (10) |  Marner (4) |  Grubauer (9) |  Pacioretty (14) |
| Round 2 |  Hamilton (6.5) |  Burakovsky (4) |  Pastrnak (18) |  Tavares (0) |  Draisaitl (5) |  Landeskog (14) |  Barkov (7) |  Marchand (14) |  Aho (13) |  Fleury (15.5) |
| Round 3 |  Svechnikov (8) |  Barrie (1) |  Hall (5) |  Nylander (9) |  Vasilevskiy (37) |  Crosby (2) |  Ovechkin (4) |  Hedman (25.5) |  Point (27) |  Nugent-Hopkins (2) |
| Round 4 |  Toews (6.5) |  Kadri (1) |  Verhaeghe (3) |  Rask (9) |  Guentzel (2) |  Nedeljkovic (8) |  Marchessault (11) |  Girard (5.5) |  Stamkos (21) |  Bergeron (10) |
| Round 5 |  Trocheck (3) |  Palat (16) |  Campbell (6.5) |  Donskoi (5) |  Letang (7) |  Necas (5) |  Huberdeau (10) |  Rielly (4.5) |  Theodore (10.5) |  Karlsson (16) |
| Round 6 |  Saad (8) |  Gourde (11) |  Rust (3) |  Hyman (1) |  Nurse (1) |  Malkin (5) |  Backstrom (1) |  Krejci (9) |  Teravainen (6) |  Smith (6) |
| Round 7 |  Newhook (3) |  Puljujarvi (2) |  Kaprizov (3) |  McAvoy (17) |  Sergachev (4) |  Spezza (5) |  Pietrangelo (14) |  Tuch (10) |  Stephenson (6) |  Grzelcyk (4.5) |
| Round 8 |  Scheifele (5) |  Mantha (2) |  Jarry (3) |  Staal (10) |  Smith (0) |  Galchenyuk (4) |  Carlson (3) |  Lehner (1.5) |  Niederreiter (2) |  Yamamoto (1) |
| Round 9 |  Connor (8) |  Wilson (2) |  Bennett (5) |  Mrazek (1.5) |  O'Reilly (3) |  Smith (11) |  Wheeler (5) |  Killorn (18) |  Varlamov (10.5) |  Duclair (0) |
| Round 10 |  Eberle (11) |  Coleman (14) |  Foligno (1) |  Nichushkin (3) |  Perron (0) |  Carter (6) |  Hellebuyck (8) |  Ehlers (4) |  Barzal (15) |  Chiasson (1) |
| Round 11 |  Nelson (14) |  McCann (1) |  Josi (5) |  Kapanen (3) |  Cirelli (14) |  Dubnyk (0) |  Vanecek (0) |  Compher (3) |  Petry (7.5) |  Toffoli (17.5) |
| Round 12 |  Fast (3) |  Jost (4) |  Zuccarello (3) |  Pesce (5) |  Kuznetsov (0) |  Oshie (4) |  Bobrovsky (1.5) |  Muzzin (3) |  Timmins (0) |  Hornqvist (5) |
| TOTAL | 95 | 62 | 61.5 | 78.5 | 106 | 77 | 74.5 | 102 | 127.5 | 92.5 |
