| Dan | Jr | Melissa | Nigel | Matt | Tim | Sibany | Mukul | Gavin | Gy | |
| Round 1 | Martin Brodeur - 9.5 | Daniel Briere - 16 | Pavel Datsyuk - 18 | Dany Heatley - 25 | Chris Pronger - 20.5 | Chris Drury - 16 | Teemu Selanne - 19 | Sidney Crosby - 6 | Jason Spezza - 23 | Ryan Miller - 13.5 |
| Round 2 | Jaromir Jagr - 11 | Jason Pominville - 10 | Maxim Afinogenov - 11 | Miikka Kiprusoff - 3 | Thomas Vanek - 12 | Henrik Zetterberg - 15 | Roberto Luongo - 7.5 | Dominik Hasek - 19 | Scott Niedermayer - 18.5 | Joe Thornton - 11 |
| Round 3 | Jean-Sebastien Giguere - 23.5 | Patrick Marleau - 7 | Daniel Alfredsson - 28 | Martin St.Louis - 8 | Andy McDonald - 18 | Nicklas Lidstrom - 26 | Vincent Lecavalier - 8 | Brad Richards - 8 | Patrik Elias - 10 | Ray Emery - 26.5 |
| Round 4 | Evgeni Malkin - 4 | Jonathan Cheechoo - 7 | Mathieu Schneider - 9 | Evgeni Nabokov - 11 | Henrik Sedin - 5 | Marian Hossa - 1 | Daniel Sedin - 5 | Sergei Gonchar - 6 | Paul Kariya - 2 | Derek Roy - 7 |
| Round 5 | Marty Turco - 10.5 | Tim Connolly - 9 | Jochen Hecht - 6 | Alex Tanguay - 4 | Brian Gionta - 10 | Mike Modano - 3 | Ilya Kovalchuk - 2 | Peter Forsberg - 4 | Jarome Iginla - 5 | Brian Rafalski - 10.5 |
| Round 6 | Scott Gomez - 15 | Michael Nylander - 17 | Wade Redden - 15.5 | Milan Michalek - 7 | Jaroslav Spacek - 0 | Steve Sullivan - 0 | Bill Guerin - 2 | Dan Boyle - 1.5 | Markus Naslund - 5 | Marian Gaborik - 6 |
| Round 7 | Ryan Getzlaf - 23 | Chris Kunitz - 8 | Tomas Holmstrom - 9 | J.P. Dumont - 8 | Zach Parise - 11 | Brian Campbell - 9.5 | Robert Lang - 8 | Henrik Lundqvist - 11 | Corey Perry - 18 | Ales Kotalik - 4 |
| Round 8 | Vesa Toskala - 0 | Marc-Andre Fleury - 1.5 | Francois Beauchemin - 12.5 | Ryan Whitney - 2.5 | Kevin Bieksa - 0 | Todd Bertuzzi - 7 | Jordan Staal - 3 | Brendan Shanahan - 9 | Jason Arnott - 3 | Jamie Langenbrunner - 9 |
| Round 9 | Tomas Vokoun - 1.5 | Mattias Ohlund - 8.5 | Dmitri Kalinin - 6 | Brian Rolston - 2 | Kristian Huselius - 2 | Mike Comrie - 7 | Gary Roberts - 4 | Mark Recchi - 4 | Mike Fisher - 13 | Martin Straka - 10 |
| Round 10 | Sean Avery - 5 | Michel Ouellet - 2 | Kris Draper - 2 | Pavol Demitra - 4 | Dion Phaneuf - 1.5 | Drew Stafford - 4 | Brendan Morrison - 4 | Dustin Penner - 12 | John Madden - 2 | Slava Kozlov - 0 |
| TOTAL | 103 | 86 | 117 | 74.5 | 80 | 88.5 | 62.5 | 80.5 | 99.5 | 97.5 |